Today we’re delving into the world weight loss clubs, specifically Slimming World and what the program promises vs. what it delivers. We share our experience working with individuals who have previously been part of weight loss clubs and talk through the prevalence of disordered eating habits that tend to follow these restrictive programs.
3:37 Slimming World (SW) is a major commercial weight loss company based in the UK. It was founded in 1969 and has grown to 5.5 million members across the world. While the website reads as a promising solution, there are some significant problems with the Slimming World Program.
5:17 The program is based on the “food optimizing eating plan” focused on “free foods, healthy extras, and syns.” This plan is focused on restricting "syns" - assigned values to foods based on calories, fat, and fiber content, though SW claims to not count calories.
8:27 Success long term has not been shown. SW promotes disordered habits by focusing solely on short term weight loss. The idea of social support via group meetings sounds positive, but tends to be more harmful than helpful.
11:50 The “syn” system is confusing and doesn’t promote education around food choices. The plans focus on restrictive rules, guilt around "syns", and demonizing certain foods which can lead to unhealthy relationships with food.
15:23 What is the longevity of SW and similar programs? Confusing rules and regulations keep you reliant upon a system that doesn’t lead to sustainable habits.
19:00 SW consultants aren’t credentialed in a way that leads to optimal support for SW members. When we have worked with individuals who have been SW consultants or members, many individuals have reported disordered eating habits starting with these weight loss groups.
22:30 There are so many negative repercussions of making weight loss our only goal, including increased risk of ED and disordered eating habits.
26:55 The group meeting formats place all stock in weight as the only measure of progress, going as far as weight shaming publicly if individuals have not lost weight. This ignores the fact that our weight fluctuates, and that weight is only one (often unreliable) measure of change for those with WL goals.
31:13 The false marketing around SW’s approach creates an appearance of flexibility or longevity that masks disordered behaviors and restrictive rules.
One of Michael’s posts on SW: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Ckft0EgIHK9/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA%3D%3D
Don't miss future episodes! Subscribe to our podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.
Follow along with Michael at @michaelulloapt on IG, Threads, Twitter, and Tik Tok
https://www.michaelulloa.com/
Follow along with Kate at @klnutrition on IG and threads
https://www.katelymannutrition.com/
Today we’re delving into the world weight loss clubs, specifically Slimming World and what the program promises vs. what it delivers. We share our experience working with individuals who have previously been part of weight loss clubs and talk through the prevalence of disordered eating habits that tend to follow these restrictive programs.
3:37 Slimming World (SW) is a major commercial weight loss company based in the UK. It was founded in 1969 and has grown to 5.5 million members across the world. While the website reads as a promising solution, there are some significant problems with the Slimming World Program.
5:17 The program is based on the “food optimizing eating plan” focused on “free foods, healthy extras, and syns.” This plan is focused on restricting "syns" - assigned values to foods based on calories, fat, and fiber content, though SW claims to not count calories.
8:27 Success long term has not been shown. SW promotes disordered habits by focusing solely on short term weight loss. The idea of social support via group meetings sounds positive, but tends to be more harmful than helpful.
11:50 The “syn” system is confusing and doesn’t promote education around food choices. The plans focus on restrictive rules, guilt around "syns", and demonizing certain foods which can lead to unhealthy relationships with food.
15:23 What is the longevity of SW and similar programs? Confusing rules and regulations keep you reliant upon a system that doesn’t lead to sustainable habits.
19:00 SW consultants aren’t credentialed in a way that leads to optimal support for SW members. When we have worked with individuals who have been SW consultants or members, many individuals have reported disordered eating habits starting with these weight loss groups.
22:30 There are so many negative repercussions of making weight loss our only goal, including increased risk of ED and disordered eating habits.
26:55 The group meeting formats place all stock in weight as the only measure of progress, going as far as weight shaming publicly if individuals have not lost weight. This ignores the fact that our weight fluctuates, and that weight is only one (often unreliable) measure of change for those with WL goals.
31:13 The false marketing around SW’s approach creates an appearance of flexibility or longevity that masks disordered behaviors and restrictive rules.
One of Michael’s posts on SW: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Ckft0EgIHK9/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA%3D%3D
Don't miss future episodes! Subscribe to our podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.
Follow along with Michael at @michaelulloapt on IG, Threads, Twitter, and Tik Tok
https://www.michaelulloa.com/
Follow along with Kate at @klnutrition on IG and threads
https://www.katelymannutrition.com/